ブログに戻る

The Reddit account that never gets banned is the one that actually uses Reddit.

Shawn Tenam··8分で読める·gtm-engineering

Shawn Tenam's Reddit profile: 1,703 post karma, 907 comment karma, and the Clearbox opportunity inbox behind it.

Clearbox finds the Reddit threads where your buyers are already asking for what you sell, labels them lead, competitor, or engage, and puts them in front of you. That is the software half. The other half is the account you reply from, and that half is the one people get banned on.

I have 2,610 karma, 212 posts, 609 comments, and 1.6 million views on one account, and 162 Clearbox signups behind it. This is the playbook I run: what I do, what I refuse to do, and how the account got stronger by being used like a normal person uses Reddit, dog pictures included.

People buy the founder

I did not try Adam Robinson's products because of a feature list. I tried them because they were Adam Robinson's, and I had watched him build in public long enough to trust what came out of it. That is how I buy, and it is how the founders I talk to buy. Nobody in these conversations is buying a Reddit tool. They are buying the experience of the person who has already done the thing on Reddit, and a way to borrow it.

So the playbook is public. Every rule below is something I do on my own account, with the numbers to check it against.

The receipts

As of this morning: 2,610 karma, split 1,703 from posts and 907 from comments. 212 posts and 609 comments, so the activity leans hard toward comments even though the karma leans toward posts. 1.6 million views on this one account. Twenty-five posts or comments that turned into a real conversation, twenty of them tracked to a lead. 162 Clearbox signups in three months.

And one picture of my dog in r/shiba, 147 upvotes. That post is not a trick. It is the point, and I will get to why.

What to do, and what not to do

Every thread arrives labeled lead, competitor, or engage. What you do next is different for each.

DO comment before you post. Answer questions you already know the answer to. Ask a follow-up when you do not. Comments are how the community learns who you are before you ask for its attention, and they are where I built the position to publish anything bigger. DON'T open with a post that needs the community to already trust you. It will not, and the mods will read it as a campaign.

DO answer the question completely. The whole answer, in the thread, with nothing held back for the click. DON'T drop the link. Every DM I get on Reddit starts the same way: I answered someone in a thread, and a day later they messaged me asking for the link I never posted. People ask when the answer was good. Dropping it uninvited turns the same answer into spam.

DO use Reddit like a person. Pick home communities you would still read if your company disappeared. Post the dog. Argue about code. Ask about apartments. My r/shiba post is part of this account's history, and it makes the account stronger, because Reddit and its moderators can see a person, not a channel. DON'T only show up when your category comes up. An account that activates only around its own product is a campaign, and it reads like one to everyone who checks the profile.

DO read the room before you reply. Sort the thread. See who else is promoting in it and how the room is reacting to them. If three vendors have already dropped their pitch and the replies are cold, the thread is telling you what a fourth pitch will get. DON'T pile on a thread where a real user is already recommending you. Arriving behind them to validate your own praise makes the praise look staged. Leave it.

DO treat competitor threads as data. More on this below, because it is the part of the channel almost nobody uses. DON'T argue with a competitor, ever. Nobody in the thread is on your side in that fight, and the mods remember it.

DO disclose the affiliation when your product comes up. Disclosure does not rescue a bad pitch, it makes a relevant answer honest. DON'T pretend to be a happy customer. That is the one that gets the account and the company name flagged together.

DO scroll, read, and upvote every day like a regular user. Open the app. Read your home feed. Upvote what deserves it. Reply to something that has nothing to do with work. This is the habit that keeps an account looking like an account, and it takes ten minutes. DON'T let anything automated touch the public side. Monitoring, classifying, drafting an angle, all fine. Posting, commenting, voting, following, never. Reddit's own numbers from July: its newer defenses were blocking about 23 million spam views a day and catching around 25,000 spammy posts and comments. Assume it gets better every month.

DO make NO-REPLY a real outcome. The reply-engine skill I open-sourced gates every opportunity: GO means timely and ready, REVIEW means check the thread and the subreddit rules first, NO-REPLY means log the intelligence and stay out. In the proving batch, one of the strongest rows was a NO-REPLY. DON'T reply to everything the tool surfaces. The skip discipline is what keeps the reply rate low enough to stay welcome.

DO stay in the comments after you post. Reply to the person who found the edge case. Share the repo when someone asks. Update the post when a correction deserves it. DON'T post and leave. A post with no follow-through is distribution. A post where the author stays is a conversation.

DO track what a thread becomes. Profile visit, DM, signup, call. That is the outcome. DON'T count karma as the result. Karma tells you the work got a response. It does not tell you whether the work moved anyone.

How accounts get banned, and why mine has not been

The bans I see in my own signups are never mysterious. A new account that posts links in week one. The same comment pasted across five subreddits. An account that only ever appears in threads about its own category. Posting or voting run by a script. Reposting something a moderator removed. Any of those on its own can do it, and B2B founders usually do three at once, because that is what the growth-hack version of Reddit tells you to do.

The inverse is the list above. Comment first. Answer fully. Be a person. Read the room. Disclose. Scroll daily. Skip when the gate says skip. Stay in the thread. None of that is a trick, which is why it works, and why it compounds instead of resetting every time a policy changes.

The tool matters here too. Clearbox never connects to your Reddit account. It does not log in as you, post for you, vote for you, or follow anyone. It sits entirely on the read side, watching the market and surfacing the moments. You engage from your own account, with your own hands. So when a team goes all in on the signal, the tool cannot be the reason the account goes down. The only thing that can is the list above, and the list is on you. That is a feature.

Competitor threads are data

The API hands your agent the label and the score: this thread is a competitor mention, here is how strong. The UI is where you watch the room react. Are people praising the competitor or venting about it. Who else has shown up to promote, and how did the thread treat them. Which complaint keeps repeating.

Read that way, one competitor thread is three kinds of data. Product data: what people wish the competitor did, which is a roadmap you did not have to research. Marketing data: the exact words unhappy users use, which become the words on your page. Sales data: who is unhappy right now, in public, with a timestamp. The reply, if there is one, comes last, and often the right move is no reply and a note in your own store.

One competitor thread read as product, marketing, and sales data. The reply comes last.

That is what the competitor filter is for. Not a fight. A read.

Where Clearbox fits, and where I come in

The software is opportunity distribution. The threads where your buyers are asking, labeled lead, competitor, or engage, scored, and arriving in one inbox, with an API so your own agent can read the same thing. It never touches your account.

The rest is the part people are actually buying, and I am now offering it as a service, worked with you rather than handed to you: picking the communities that fit your market, custom signals for what your buyers actually say, reviewing replies before they go out, and direct access to me while your account builds the history that makes any of this work. Some teams need better signals. Some need help choosing rooms. Some already have the opportunities and need someone to show them where to stop.

Start here

Sign up at clearbox.to/sign-up. You will have live opportunities and your own API endpoint on day one, and nothing about your Reddit account changes.

If you want me to work it with you, reply to the newsletter, or grab a slot, with what you sell and where you think your buyers are talking. I will tell you straight whether Reddit is a channel for you before either of us spends anything.

The wiring under all of this, the API your coding agent reads, went up on the blog today: Your coding agent can read your Reddit market from one URL.

Read or share the blog version of this playbook: The Reddit account that never gets banned is the one that actually uses Reddit.

Shawn Tenam / the GTM alchemist / being real compounds

Source notes

built with Next.js · Tailwind · Claude · Remotion